Dr. Wilmer Leon: Dr. Ben Carson, Great Surgeon but a Bad Icon for the Political Collective | Kulture Kritic
Connect with us

Dr. Wilmer Leon: Dr. Ben Carson, Great Surgeon but a Bad Icon for the Political Collective


Dr. Wilmer Leon: Dr. Ben Carson, Great Surgeon but a Bad Icon for the Political Collective



Dr. Wilmer J. Leon III

 “Nobody is starving on the streets (of America).  We have always taken care of them.  We have churches which actually are much better mechanisms for taking care of the poor because they are right there with them.  This is one of the reasons we give tax breaks to churches…” Dr. Ben Carson – CPAC Speech 2013

In modern culture, an icon is a symbol – i.e. a name, face, picture, or even a person readily recognized as having some well-known significance or embodying certain qualities.  That face or person begins to represent something else of greater significance through literal or figurative meaning. With his speech at the 2013 National Prayer Breakfast and his recent CPAC speech, Carson has become the new Black conservative darling.  He’s a great pediatric surgeon but a terrible icon for the political collective.

Dr. Ben Carson has an incredibly compelling and motivational story.  Born into poverty in Detroit in 1951 and raised by a single mother with a third-grade education, Carson became the first surgeon to separate conjoined twins and the youngest to head a surgical department.  His focus, work ethic, and commitment to excellence should be emulated by as many as possible.

One problem with Dr. Carson and others like him – i.e. Justice Thomas, Michael Steele, Wardell Connerly and Condoleezza Rice is how they have lent their voices and their personal narratives to conservatives in ways that allow them to undermine the social safety net in America.  The argument is that these individuals have overachieved in spite of the odds; therefore, the inability of the poor in America to rise into the middle class or beyond is due to personal failure, lack of drive, initiative, and dependence upon the system. Carson, Rice, and Thomas made it; why can’t you?

Another problem with their “realities” is their failure to recognize and/or admit how they benefitted from “the system” at some point in their struggle.  For example, Wardell Connerly grew his business in part with assistance from the 8(a) Program.  Justice Thomas was a beneficiary of Affirmative Action.  I don’t know if Carson’s mother ever received any public assistance during his childhood but if she did not I am certain some of his neighbors did. Is he ready to cast them all as lazy and totally dependent upon the government?

We love to hear stories about people overcoming great odds to achieve success. What is ignored when reciting the stories of the Carson’s, Thomas’, and Rice’s of the world is depth of the chasm that lied between Africans in America and later the African American community and white America. There have always been personal successes in the midst of the collective or group struggle. During the 18th century while hundreds of thousands and later millions of Africans in America where bound by the shackles of slavery, individuals such as Olaudah Equiano aka “Equiano, the African” and James Forten found success on American shores.  Did the success of Equiano, Forten and others negate the suffering and systemic oppression of those enslaved?  Obviously not.

Today, in spite of all of the disturbing data documenting the disparity between the African American community and Whites, such as eighteen percent unemployment, African Americans being fifty-three percent of those incarcerated and only thirteen percent of the population, the wealth disparity, high school drop-out rates, college graduation rates, home foreclosure rates, etc. the likes of a Wardell Connerly, Shelby Steele, or Clarence Thomas stand before conservatives and argue that we no longer need Affirmative Action, Head Start, and other social programs.

READ  Ancient Egyptian Woman With 70 Hair Extensions Discovered

Individual success should never become the standard of measure of success for the collective. It is only through group success that the African American community will truly become politically and economically empowered.

Dr. Ben Carson made some very inaccurate and dangerous statements during his CPAC speech that cannot go unchallenged.  He stated as referenced above, “Nobody is starving on the streets (of America)”.  According to Bread for the World, “14.5 percent of U.S. households struggle to put enough food on the table. More than 48 million Americans—including 16.2 million children—live in these households…Among African-Americans and Latinos, nearly one in three children is at risk of hunger.”  Has he forgotten that in 1951 he may have been one of those hungry children?

He also stated, “Many people don’t know this but socialism started as a reaction to America because people in Europe, they looked at us and said, “”wait a minute look at those Americans…people like Henry Ford, Kellogg, Vanderbilt…they’ve got so much money…”” it needs to be redistributed.”  Actually, the term socialism is attributed to Pierre Leroux and Robert Owen around 1827.  Henry Ford was not born until 1863.  Socialist models and ideas espousing common or public ownership have existed since antiquity. Karl Marx, considered by many to be the founder of modern socialism first published Das Kapital in 1847.  Henry Ford was 4 years old.  Socialism was actually a reaction to the Industrial Revolution which started in Britain around 1760.

Carson said, “People don’t want to talk about God…let’s let everybody believe what they want to believe.”  Actually, the basis of the free exercise clause of the First Amendment is the freedom to believe.  It is one of the few absolute protections that the Constitution provides.  There is a big difference between belief and practice. If Carson understood the Constitution he would know that.

Dr. Ben Carson has a very motivational story but his political analysis and message lack real understanding of the issues necessary to be taken seriously.  It is dangerous to use the success of an individual(s) as the basis of a sociological or economic indictment of an entire class of individuals.  A reporter once asked Dr. Carson why he never talked about race to which he responded, “…because I’m a neurosurgeon”.  Well, Dr. Carson, I’ll make a deal with you, I’ll stay out of the operating room if you leave the political analysis and dialogue to trained professionals.

Dr. Wilmer Leon is the Producer/ Host of the nationally broadcast call-in talk radio program “Inside the Issues with Leon,” and a Lecturer e in the Department of Political Science at HowardUniversity in Washington, D.C.  Go to www.wilmerleon.com or email: [email protected] www.twitter.com/drwleon and Dr. Leon’s Prescription at Faacebook.com

© 2013 InfoWave Communications, LLC

Loading Facebook Comments ...


  1. Mother-Nature

    March 23, 2013 at 12:36 pm

    This article is a good analysis of Dr. Carson’s moments in the sun. It has been very dissapointing to see him suck up in to the FOX NEWS klan…with Hannity and Limbaugh. They don’t believe in much SCIENCE (or facts) …so just how would Dr. Carson…being a medical scientist — fit in with that bunch of nuts???

    We might also point out that he has stated that is mother was illiterate…and that she was poor when he was growing up. Some people do claim that Dr. Carson did receive benefits and funds from the Gov’t — such as FOOD STAMPS, GOV’T AID, PUBLIC HOUSING, PELL GRANTS, etc.

    He is to be commended for his great achievements…but he should stay out of POLITICS and continue work with his FOUNDATION.

  2. Latrice

    March 23, 2013 at 1:29 pm

    Its like a disease in the black community, closing the door behind you. It seems as if when we make it, we forget the help we received on the way up. I think we want to be the only one seen, sso we climb the ladder then pull it up behind us. This way it looks as if we were the only one to make it. Whatever the reason, its sad. I have to say though, someone should remind them of this: you are still judged by the least of us

  3. W Lyons

    March 23, 2013 at 1:37 pm

    “Individual success should never become the standard of measure of success for the collective. It is only through group success that the African American community will truly become politically and economically empowered.”

    The Black community already has a good deal of political power, which was clearly reflected in the election of President Obama.

    However, in America at the individual level there is no direct link between political power (one man/woman = one vote, which is guaranteed by the Constitution) and economic power (no one has a Constitutional right to a decent job and government benefits will never be generous enough to give beneficiaries “economic power”).

    The Black community’s economic power can only come when Black America finds equality in employment opportunity and reality, which has to be preceded by equality of education, colorblind hiring, etc.

    The economic success that then follows for many individuals in the group will be required before the group can have economic success. No amount of new law, government benefits, etc. can ever really confer “economic power” on the the group.

  4. charles mcghee

    March 23, 2013 at 2:23 pm

    I’ll take Dr. Carson political opinion over Tom Joyner any day:

  5. PinkRose

    March 23, 2013 at 3:08 pm

    What I took Dr. Carson’s statement about there not being people starving in the streets to mean is that if we can afford a fresh new weave and the latest Jordan’s, then we shouldn’t be complaining.

  6. Diana W. White

    March 23, 2013 at 5:29 pm


  7. ana

    March 23, 2013 at 6:08 pm

    Dr.Carson,please be careful of these detractors,they are just a puppet,all dressed up with pomp and grandeur. Do not listen to these Shallow Egotistic Palookas.

  8. Ruby from NJ

    March 23, 2013 at 7:22 pm

    To edit: ” … [T]he depth of the chasm that lied (sic) between Africans in America …. ” should read: ” … [T]he depth of the chasm that lay between Africans in America …. “

  9. bernina200

    March 23, 2013 at 9:48 pm

    Dr. Carson, you are being used by the TEAPUBLICAN, surly a man of you intelligence, and out look at this big world, you know better, but it is obvious, you are no better than the Rappers, that sang (not sign) about street life.
    By the time you realize what is happening to you it will be to late.
    You are that slave that got on the ship and pulled the ladder up behind you so no other slave could get help (on board). Wake up. If you will remember Micheal Steel, was elected as the head of the Republican, party, because Republican, thought he could head of the President, but no such luck, you are in that same position my brother.


    March 31, 2013 at 3:45 pm

    First, let me say you are one good looking man.

    Dr. Carson, is exercising his freedom of speech and he is certainly entitled to his opinion.

    I think we should embrace differences in opinions because it may cause us to become more effective. For example, we may get pissed off enough and do better.

  11. こんにちは 私の家族! I したい書かれており、|、素敵な偉大 | | 素晴らしい素晴らしいで、これはポストは記事がと言う付属して ほぼほぼ全て重要に関する情報。のように見に もっとこのようなポスト| 私はだろう私がいただきたいです。
    銀行為替 商品到着後レビュー記載でプレゼント http://kumarmaintenance.com/full-20441-168.html

  12. 緊急大幅値下げ 即日出荷

    September 4, 2015 at 4:45 pm

    こんにちはねえあり、あなたがした仕事| 優れた偉大な 行っ行わ。 私がよ 確かこれをDiggや個別 |私の友人にお勧めしますを示唆しています。 私は 自信が 彼らがよこのの恩恵を受けたこと。
    緊急大幅値下げ 即日出荷 http://www.playcadia.com/budget-25024-201.html

  13. 土日祝も発送 上品な高級感漂う

    September 4, 2015 at 4:58 pm

    このような良い共有おかげをサポートするために 思考を、執筆の作品です完全私は完全にそれを読んでいるなぜthatsの、気難しく|良い|楽しい|素敵な
    土日祝も発送 上品な高級感漂う http://www.virusexperts.org/call-24993-164.html

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Commentary


Follow Us On Facebook

Our Team

To Top